Close this search box.
Close this search box.
Close this search box.

No QA? All QA!


One of the major topics that intimidate test engineers is the No-QA question or approach (depending on your view of it).

I heard such responses after the session “Fiverr delivering fast..No QA”, by Gil Wasserman, Fiverr VP R&D, at our Agile Israel 2016 event. QA members asked me if they should look for their next role, and I keep hearing this concern whenever this topic arises.

So, is it true? Should we eliminate the QA role? Or better say – merge it into the developer’s role?

I truly understand the motivation for a No-QA approach – We do want to have a shared team responsibility for quality. We want the team to own it. We want developers to develop quality code and quality products and not to hand over the code to someone else’s problem. But I found that the No-QA way of doing it provides a contradictory message. If we eliminate the QA how will we increase the quality? How will we focus the developer’s attention on quality? What do we expect them to do?

Does this mean that there is no need for QA as team members? No QA expertise that should be valued?

Well, if we eliminate the QA role we don’t leave much choice for the developers other than to tell them that there is no one else to test, so they have to.

It’s like homework, you can hate doing it, but if you don’t – how will you learn? And yes, developers resist doing testing, but if they won’t – how will they learn? How will they value their code, their solutions, and the user flow? How will they improve the product’s testability and support?

But No-QA? Can they just do it? Don’t they need guidance, or assistance? Someone that will help them make their environment more supportive for testing and quality improvements, someone that will help them criticize the product, its solutions, and technology, someone that will guide them in thinking from the customer’s point of view?
This is where the QA team member gets in.  In the webinar of Quality at Speed, How JIRA Does QA they call QA – quality assistance.

I really like this term, because test engineers should not be quality controllers, instead they should assist in building quality into the process, and grow their team’s quality consciousness and practices.

They should use their creativity to run exploratory testing, to better represent the user, by setting better test environments and assist in defining better user stories, MMFs (Minimum Marketable Features), and MVPs (Minimum Viable Products).

They should question if you are building the right it rather than if you built it right, as greatly discussed in GTAC 2011: Opening Keynote Address – Test is Dead.

They should inspire others by promoting test-first approaches, defining automation & TDD (Test Driven Development) as well as working closely with developers on defining UT (Unit Tests). They should assist in becoming an All-QA.

As such, the ratio of Quality Assistance doesn’t have to grow. You can keep a small community of QA to provide higher quality and the fastest speed. You can make the developers build AND also evaluate their outcomes, relieving the QA bottleneck, but without ignoring the QA added value. Instead, you leverage it.

In organizations that develop complicated products or projects, that require domain/field expertise, merging the QA role into the developer’s one is not an easy and sometimes not a doable path. In the same way that developers hold their main expertise and can do some in other areas, including testing (being more T-shaped members), there is a place in the team to hold test assistance that can be experts in a certain domain of testing and also guide others towards better quality and contribute to other team’s areas as automation, pairing with developers on UT and TDD and so forth. The magic word here is balance. Balancing dev-test work within the teams and balancing shared team ownership and individual distinctiveness.

In an HBR article of the-problem-with-rewarding-individual-performers, Jay Van Bavel and Dominic Packer wrote that “By balancing individuals’ need to belong with their desire to stand out, a leader can build a sense of “optimal distinctiveness” among group members”.

I find it a real art to keeping optimal distinctiveness in the team. To relieve the threat of a cross-functional team with T-shaped people and shared ownership of quality, and still keep the team members as individuals, that are being recognized for their distinct expertise that contributes to the team.

So, No-QA or All-QA? Yes, I think that words reflect and impact our mindset. Therefore, an ALL-QA approach is better than No-QA.

QA has lots to do with building quality, assisting developers to test, ensuring that quality can be enabled, qualifying that the organization is building the right it, and making quality an asset of ALL the team.

What do you think?

Subscribe for Email Updates:



Advanced Roadmaps
Reading List
The Kanban Method
What Is Kanban
Agile Delivery
Sprint Iteration
Business Agility
Continuous Improvement
Scrum Values
Agile Assembly Architecture
Managing Projects
Agile Risk Management
Agile Project Management
An Appreciative Retrospective
RTE Role
User stories
Lean Agile Basics
Lean-Agile Budgeting
Agile and DevOps Journey
Process Improvement
Enterprise DevOps
Limiting Work in Progress
Agile for Embedded Systems
Agile Product Development
Introduction to Test Driven Development
Legacy Code
Scrum Master Role
Agile Release Management
Continuous Planning
Story Slicing
Lean Budgeting
Test Driven Development
Agile Testing Practices
IT Operations
Kanban 101
The Agile Coach
Legacy Enterprise
Jira admin
Lean Startup
Continuous Integration
Applying Agile Methodology
PI Planning
Risk-aware Product Development
Releases Using Lean
Development Value Streams
Value Streams
Product Management
Agile India
Nexus Integration Team
Quality Assurance
Lean and Agile Principles and Practices
Agile Techniques
Continuous Deployment
PI Objectives
Pomodoro Technique
Software Development
Lean Agile
Professional Scrum with Kanban
System Archetypes
Jira Cloud
speed @ scale
Agile Development
Acceptance Test-Driven Development
Professional Scrum Product Owner
Lean Agile Management
Implementing SAFe
speed at scale
Portfolio for Jira
Built-In Quality
Agile Project
Kaizen Workshop
Jira Plans
ScrumMaster Tales
Lean Agile Leadership
Team Flow
Keith Sawyer
Agile Outsourcing
Risk Management on Agile Projects
Nexus and Kanban
SAFe Release Planning
Scrum Guide
Coaching Agile Teams
Games and Exercises
Large Scale Scrum
Iterative Incremental Development
Product Ownership
Agile Mindset
Risk Management in Kanban
Achieve Business Agility
Manage Budget Creation
Software Development Estimation
Lean Risk Management
Hybrid Work
Change Management
Scaled Agile Framework
AI Artificial Intelligence
Managing Risk on Agile Projects
Agile Product Ownership
Scrum Master
Daily Scrum
ART Success
SAFe DevOps
Continuous Delivery
Introduction to ATDD
Certified SAFe
Elastic Leadership
Operational Value Stream
Kanban Basics
Program Increment
Professional Scrum Master
lean agile change management
Lean Agile Organization
Agile Games and Exercises
Agile Contracts Best Practices
Scrum and XP
Nexus and SAFe
Lean Software Development
Engineering Practices
Agile Israel
Nexus vs SAFe
Accelerate Value Delivery At Scale
Effective Agile Retrospectives
Scrum Primer
A Kanban System for Software Engineering
Perfection Game
Kanban Kickstart Example
Sprint Planning
Agile Program
Lean-Agile Software Development
Agile Release Planning
Agile Basics
System Integration Environments
Sprint Retrospectives
Agile in the Enterprise
Agile Exercises
Entrepreneurial Operating System®
System Team
Artificial Intelligence
Kanban Game
Principles of Lean-Agile Leadership
Agile Games
Agile Israel Events
Agile Community
Agile Marketing
Release Train Engineer
Rapid RTC
Lean and Agile Techniques
ALM Tools
Systems Thinking
Implementation of Lean and Agile
Enable registration in settings - general

Contact Us

Request for additional information and prices

AgileSparks Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter, and stay updated on the latest Agile news and events

This website uses Cookies to provide a better experience
Shopping cart