Search
Close this search box.
Search
Close this search box.
Search
Close this search box.

Uncertainty & the Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe™)

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
WhatsApp

What is the connection between Uncertainty and the Scaled Agile Framework?

Uncertainty is one of the core reasons we need to be agile. Different modes of Business/Requirements/Technology uncertainties impact our economic costs in product development – especially the potential impact of risk. The first principle of SAFe™ is “Take an economic view”. I frequently use my “uncertainty filter glasses” to take an alternative economic view. I find it helps Scaled Agile/SAFe™ practitioners/leaders understand both the need for Agility as well as examine various work system design considerations. In this article, I introduce the Stacey Matrix which is one of my favorite models for understanding the uncertainty landscape as well as the implications of uncertainty on various specific SAFe™ design decisions.

Making it Concrete – The Stacey Uncertainty Matrix and its relation to the Scaled Agile Framework

stacey1

As I wrote about at some length in Risk-Aware Product Development (a.k.a Agile) explaining the concept of Requirement/Business/Technology uncertainty is one of the first things I do with most audiences I meet for the first time. In a Leading SAFe/SPC class this typically takes place in the first module when we go over the need for SAFe. This is not a core part of the materials but I take the time to explain it anyhow and then find myself referring back to it throughout the workshop.

The first layer of realization is that our problem with the classic approaches to product development is that they were built for complicated endeavors but not complex ones.

Then we layer on more interesting realizations like the fact that for some endeavors like those approaching the “Anarchy”/”Chaos” domains probably the best approach would be a “Skunkworks” style cross-functional co-located fully empowered small team. As you grow a bit farther from Anarchy you can scale agility using an approach like the Scaled Agile Framework. At these levels of uncertainty/risk the trade-off of distributed teams, distributed PI Planning, system team, component teams, and shared architects/UX MIGHT make sense and are worth considering.

As you approach the simpler domain sometimes even the alignment rationale for “whole train” PI Planning can be reconsidered. Is that SAFe™ heresy? maybe. But I find that telling people “Whole ART PI Planning” is mandatory is less effective than showing them WHEN it has a better economic impact. (BTW as you grow in complexity/uncertainty you also need better people that are more engaged – which the Whole ART PI Planning helps with as well)

In general, this thinking helps leaders at these workshops grasp the various economic levers that go into tailoring a SAFe™ implementation. I find this disarms some of the resistance you get when people feel something is “a must”. Using this approach they typically go out with a stronger conviction to avoid some compromises and a better feeling about the compromises that do make sense.

To take another example of how I use the uncertainty matrix during SAFe™ training/implementation discussions – SAFe™ talks about a hierarchy between ART Product Management and the Product Owners working with the teams. A typical and sensible question people have is “Who should wear the Product Owner hat?”. Using the uncertainty matrix, we realize that in some cases the Product Owner should be a Product Manager (probably the top two quadrants of the matrix) and in some other cases, he can also be a more technical leader (Especially on the far right side of the matrix). As the typical organization, I work with is struggling to fill those Product Owner roles, this realization helps them deploy their people more effectively in a way that minimizes the risk of ineffective feedback loops due to the wrong individuals being in the tight Product Owner loop.

 

In summary

Understanding uncertainty and its attributes and implications is in my view and experience a critical step of buying into the need for agile as well as gaining the ability to design an effective agile approach for your context. Presenting the Stacey Matrix and trying to map it to your reality is one technique I used to help people gain this understanding. Using it as a decision filter/design criteria for further SAFe™ tailoring questions complements this initial presentation/exposure and grounds it. If you are teaching Leading SAFe™/SPC classes, explaining the need for agile to leaders/executives, or working with an organization to implement a scaled agile approach, I believe you will see improved results if you add this technique to your toolbox. I know I have.

Subscribe for Email Updates:

Categories:

Tags:

AgileSparks
Software Development
Slides
Self-organization
Risk-aware Product Development
ART Success
Agile Marketing
Agile
speed @ scale
Scrum Master Role
Systems Thinking
A Kanban System for Software Engineering
Sprint Iteration
QA
ARTs
Agile Development
SAFe
Continuous Deployment
AI
Sprint Retrospectives
Applying Agile Methodology
SAFe Release Planning
RTE Role
Kaizen Workshop
Product Ownership
WIP
Spotify
Nexus and Kanban
SPC
Accelerate Value Delivery At Scale
Webinar
An Appreciative Retrospective
Agile Exercises
Continuous Planning
agileisrael
Agile Release Management
Principles of Lean-Agile Leadership
TDD
Agile Testing Practices
Jira
Acceptance Test-Driven Development
Lean-Agile Software Development
Scrum Guide
Scrum and XP
Amdocs
Nexus Integration Team
Lean Agile Leadership
Risk Management on Agile Projects
Agile Outsourcing
Scrum
Lean Budgeting
Agile Games and Exercises
Legacy Enterprise
ATDD vs. BDD
System Archetypes
Implementation of Lean and Agile
LPM
Lean Agile Basics
Continuous Integration
Agile Project
Lean Agile Organization
Agile India
Sprint Planning
Professional Scrum Master
Nexus
System Integration Environments
Agile Project Management
Jira Plans
Iterative Incremental Development
POPM
NIT
Lean Software Development
Agile Delivery
Frameworks
Reading List
SAFe DevOps
Lean Risk Management
Tools
Perfection Game
Engineering Practices
PI Objectives
Lean Startup
IT Operations
Manage Budget Creation
Nexus and SAFe
Legacy Code
System Team
Jira Cloud
What Is Kanban
Agile Techniques
Elastic Leadership
Atlaassian
Release Train Engineer
Agile Israel Events
Enterprise DevOps
Continuous Improvement
Agile in the Enterprise
Presentation
The Agile Coach
Agility
Certified SAFe
Portfolio for Jira
Nexus vs SAFe
Scrum Primer
Scrum Master
Agile Risk Management
ROI
predictability
ALM Tools
Code
RSA
Planning
Pomodoro Technique
Kanban Kickstart Example
Lean and Agile Techniques
Agile Release Planning
Implementing SAFe
Agile Mindset
Built-In Quality
speed at scale
Large Scale Scrum
Scrum.org
Managing Risk on Agile Projects
Agile Community
Scrum Values
Atlassian
Story Slicing
Kanban
Scrum With Kanban
Agile Assembly Architecture
Lean and Agile Principles and Practices
Agile Israel
Agile Program
The Kanban Method
Continuous Delivery
LAB
Releases Using Lean
AI Artificial Intelligence
Change Management
Lean-Agile Budgeting
DevOps
Jira admin
Achieve Business Agility
Value Streams
Process Improvement
EOS®
Coaching Agile Teams
Lean Agile
BDD
LeSS
Artificial Intelligence
Agile Contracts Best Practices
Kaizen
Software Development Estimation
Advanced Roadmaps
Introduction to ATDD
Risk Management in Kanban
Games and Exercises
Agile Games
Agile for Embedded Systems
Program Increment
Agile Product Ownership
Quality Assurance
SA
ATDD
Hybrid Work
Product Management
Daily Scrum
Development Value Streams
Test Driven Development
Agile and DevOps Journey
Kanban Game
Tips
GanttBan
Professional Scrum with Kanban
Rapid RTC
Kanban Basics
Agile Basics
Operational Value Stream
RTE
Professional Scrum Product Owner
Scaled Agile Framework
Limiting Work in Progress
Video
Lean Agile Management
Entrepreneurial Operating System®
Managing Projects
Kanban 101
Agile Product Development
Effective Agile Retrospectives
PI Planning
Introduction to Test Driven Development
Covid19
lean agile change management
Certification
ScrumMaster Tales
AgileSparks
Logo
Enable registration in settings - general

Contact Us

Request for additional information and prices

AgileSparks Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter, and stay updated on the latest Agile news and events

This website uses Cookies to provide a better experience
Shopping cart