Search
Close this search box.
Search
Close this search box.
Search
Close this search box.

Kanban Service Level Expectations and how to use them in Scrum

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
WhatsApp

One of the new concepts we introduce in the Kanban Guide for Scrum Teams is the Service Level Expectation, defined as:

An SLE forecasts how long it should take a given item to flow from start to finish within your workflow. The SLE itself has two parts: a period of elapsed days and a probability associated with that period (e.g., “85% of work items will be finished in 8 days or less” which can also be stated as “8 days with 85% confidence/probability”).

The term expectation is key here. We’re not talking about commitments or promises. While it seems like an SLE is mainly serving the team’s stakeholders its primary purpose is actually internally focused. The Development Team is using that expectation as a flow transparency, inspection, and adaptation mechanism. The team can start to actually compare active in-flight work to their SLE and look for items that are at risk of missing the SLE.

As work ages without completing, it becomes more and more likely this work item would not meet the team’s SLE. For example, once a work item reaches a point where its age is now at the point where half of the team’s work items have already been completed, it’s a clear indication that there’s more risk for this item than the typical item. We basically learn about the increased risk to specific items the more time passes without them completing. Common sense, no? The idea is that by visualizing these items and that growing risk we can focus the team’s tactical inspection and adaptation during the Daily Scrum on tackling these risky items.

Let’s look at an example. Let’s assume that indeed we have a Development Team that learns from their cycle time scatterplot that 85% of their work items finish in 8 days or less and 50% of the items actually finish within 4 days. They have item A which has been active for 5 days already and item B which has been active for 3 days. Which of these items should the team feel more confident they can finish within their 8 days or less SLE? Without further information about where each of the items is in their workflow, they should feel more confident about item B aged less. Item A has already been active more than it takes for 50% of the cards to finish, so it’s quite a strong signal that there’s a flow risk to it. Basically, with each day that passes in which a work item doesn’t finish, the probability that a work item will not meet its SLE increases”.

Beyond its usefulness for in-Sprint flow focus, SLEs are also useful during Sprint Retrospectives. The “surprise” or “anomaly” of missing your SLE can drive an improvement discussion. I previously wrote about the Sprint Forecast as an expectation and the learning/improvement value of having an expectation that you miss vs having no expectations.

This “no expectations” problem is actually a common concern for Scrum practitioners when they look at Kanban. The Sprint Forecast/Commitment provides that expectation. Kanban without SLEs indeed is missing something. Having WIP limits as expectations improves flow but doesn’t help with specific items that aren’t flowing well.

How should a Scrum Team come up with their SLE? First of all – The SLE relates to the Development Team. They should figure out what their SLE should be. If possible based on historical cycle times. If there isn’t enough data, make the best guess and replace it with empirical data-based information as soon as possible. If it isn’t based on historical cycle times, you cannot really expect to make any educated confidence-level determinations (like the one above) based on your SLE.

Also, SLEs aren’t SLA (Service Level Agreements). SLA is a loaded term that means different things in different contexts but generally is an external commitment about the service levels a team will provide. As mentioned an SLE is mainly internally focused.

Bottom line – SLEs are used by Scrum Teams to set flow expectations for themselves. SLEs are ideally created based on actual historical cycle time data. They are then used by teams to focus their flow inspection and adaptation effort – during the Sprint in the Daily Scrum and following the sprint in the Sprint Retrospective. They can also use in the Sprint Review when the team is working with stakeholders that care about the team’s cycle time.

Subscribe for Email Updates:

Categories:

Tags:

Continuous Integration
Implementing SAFe
SAFe
The Kanban Method
Presentation
Tools
Coaching Agile Teams
Agile Project
NIT
Built-In Quality
Atlaassian
agileisrael
Nexus and SAFe
Risk Management on Agile Projects
Agile Exercises
Agile Contracts Best Practices
Lean Agile Organization
Webinar
Scrum.org
PI Objectives
Agile Testing Practices
Atlassian
Applying Agile Methodology
Agile Basics
Iterative Incremental Development
Product Ownership
Self-organization
Scrum With Kanban
Agile Project Management
Continuous Improvement
Scrum Primer
Agile Israel
Scrum and XP
Certification
Agile Product Development
Lean Risk Management
Development Value Streams
ScrumMaster Tales
Team Flow
System Integration Environments
Reading List
Games and Exercises
Risk Management in Kanban
Lean-Agile Budgeting
Legacy Enterprise
Lean Startup
Lean and Agile Techniques
Agile India
Lean Agile
Risk-aware Product Development
Continuous Deployment
BDD
Portfolio for Jira
Agile Release Planning
Spotify
ARTs
Agile Games
Kanban 101
Limiting Work in Progress
Continuous Delivery
Continuous Planning
Change Management
Pomodoro Technique
Scrum Values
Engineering Practices
Planning
The Agile Coach
Process Improvement
Agile Outsourcing
Enterprise DevOps
Release Train Engineer
Agile Program
Agile Marketing
Entrepreneurial Operating System®
Releases Using Lean
Covid19
speed @ scale
WIP
AI Artificial Intelligence
Introduction to ATDD
ROI
POPM
System Archetypes
Scaled Agile Framework
Scrum
Lean Agile Leadership
ATDD
User stories
Software Development
Effective Agile Retrospectives
Agile Techniques
Tips
lean agile change management
Software Development Estimation
Video
GanttBan
Kanban Kickstart Example
Elastic Leadership
Systems Thinking
Lean Budgeting
LPM
System Team
Test Driven Development
SPC
Frameworks
Slides
Kaizen Workshop
Nexus vs SAFe
Scrum Master Role
EOS®
Nexus
Professional Scrum Master
Quality Assurance
Agile Assembly Architecture
LAB
Operational Value Stream
Agile for Embedded Systems
An Appreciative Retrospective
TDD
Code
Scrum Master
Agility
chatgpt
Agile Games and Exercises
Jira Cloud
Kanban
RSA
Agile Delivery
DevOps
Principles of Lean-Agile Leadership
Acceptance Test-Driven Development
Lean Software Development
Hybrid Work
Professional Scrum Product Owner
AI
RTE
Sprint Planning
Sprint Retrospectives
Kanban Basics
Lean and Agile Principles and Practices
PI Planning
Agile Development
Achieve Business Agility
ALM Tools
RTE Role
Jira admin
Agile Community
Agile Mindset
Jira
speed at scale
Manage Budget Creation
Story Slicing
Nexus Integration Team
Certified SAFe
Sprint Iteration
Agile Release Management
Perfection Game
Legacy Code
Agile Risk Management
IT Operations
Program Increment
Agile Product Ownership
Agile
Managing Risk on Agile Projects
SAFe Release Planning
Agile Israel Events
QA
Daily Scrum
AgileSparks
Nexus and Kanban
Kanban Game
Lean Agile Basics
Amdocs
Accelerate Value Delivery At Scale
Managing Projects
ART Success
predictability
Agile and DevOps Journey
Keith Sawyer
Value Streams
ATDD vs. BDD
Lean-Agile Software Development
Introduction to Test Driven Development
Artificial Intelligence
Scrum Guide
What Is Kanban
Business Agility
Lean Agile Management
SA
Implementation of Lean and Agile
SAFe DevOps
Large Scale Scrum
Kaizen
Advanced Roadmaps
Rapid RTC
Jira Plans
A Kanban System for Software Engineering
Professional Scrum with Kanban
Agile in the Enterprise
Product Management
AgileSparks
Logo
Enable registration in settings - general

Contact Us

Request for additional information and prices

AgileSparks Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter, and stay updated on the latest Agile news and events

This website uses Cookies to provide a better experience
Shopping cart