Explaining MVPs, MVFs, MMFs via the Lean/Agile Requirements Dinosaur

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
WhatsApp

Comment: We’re reposting here a classic article from the archives of Yuval’s personal blog

What do Agile backlog items have to do with Dinosaurs?

I’ve been using a visualization that people find useful for understanding the relationship between the various Lean/Agile requirement containers. Some people call the full model a dinosaur. Others are reminded of the snake who ate an elephant from “The Little Prince”. (I’m sure there is a good connection to elephant carpaccio somewhere in here …)

Identifying a Unique Value Proposition

IMG_0449

 

The first step is to understand that for a new product there is a unique value proposition hypothesis. This is the area where your product/service will be unique.

The Minimum Viable Product (MVP)
IMG_0450

The next step is creating a Minimum Viable Product (MVP) to test your hypothesis. This is focused on your unique value proposition but typically also provides a little bit of “Table stakes” features just to make sure it is “Viable” as a product.

Evaluating your MVP Hypothesis

IMG_0451

Your MVP is also a hypothesis. It might be good enough to find Product-Market Fit or not. The case where each potential customer you engage tells you “This is great but in order for me to use it I need X” and X is different for each customer/user is shown below. This shows you are not in a Product Market Fit yet.

Pivot?

IMG_0452

If on the other hand, you are seeing more and more answers pointing to the SAME X then it makes sense to revise your Customer/Problem/Solution Hypothesis.

IMG_0453

You essentially are executing a Pivot. You are building MVP2 focused on the new hypothesis based on recent Customer Development learning generated by the previous MVP.

IMG_0454

Growth Stage

Let’s say MVP2 is successful and you are seeing real traction of early adopters. You want to increase growth and are looking for deeper penetration of your early adopters as well as bringing on new clients some of them beyond the early adopter’s crowd. Based on feedback you’ve been collecting and your product management research you have a couple of areas that can potentially bring this growth. Some of them, by the way, extend your unique value proposition and some of them make your current product more robust.

Steady Growth with Minimally Marketable Features

IMG_0455

In the case of areas with a strong indication of value, you might go straight for Minimally Marketable Features (MMF). Finding the minimum piece that can start bringing in growth. The aim of the MMF is to bring in value. It assumes high certainty that there is value in this area and that we know what the product needs to be to provide this value. The reason to break a big feature into smaller MMFs is mainly time to market and the ability to bring in value in many areas, always keeping your option to move to another area and provide value in it rather than focusing for too long on a single direction. An indication that you are working on MMFs is that when one is being shipped you feel comfortable working on the next MMF in that area. If on the other hand, you want to wait and see if your first MMF sticks…

Experiment using MVFs

IMG_0456

…then you are back in hypothesis land. But now your hypothesis is centered on a feature rather than your product. You have an area with high potential but also high uncertainty. The way to deal with it is to build a “pioneering” feature – the Minimum Viable Feature. The minimum feature that can still be viable for real use and learning from real customers.

IMG_0457

If you learn that the MVF has hit gold you can develop more MMFs in that area to take advantage (if that makes sense). If not, you can pivot to another approach towards that feature area, or at some point look for an alternative growth path. Essentially the MVF is a mini-me version of the MVP.

Voila – The Requirements Dinosaur!

IMG_0458

There you have it. The full model. Essentially my point is that you grow a product in uncertain markets by attempting various MVPs. Then once you achieve Product-Market Fit you mix MMFs and MVFs depending on the level of Business/Requirements uncertainty in the areas you are focusing on.

While MVPs/MMFs/MVPs are atomic from a business perspective (you cannot deploy and learn from something smaller) they might be quite big from an implementation perspective.

The dinosaur carpaccio now comes in as slicing each of those pieces here into smaller slices aimed at reducing execution/technology risk. (typically these are called User Stories) Those smaller slices might have tangible business value but on the other hand, some might not. It is more important for them to provide early implementation decision feedback along the way.

Feel free to use this model. Let me know what you think about it and how I can improve it!

Subscribe for Email Updates:

Categories:

Tags:

Games and Exercises
AgileSparks
Tips
PI Objectives
Agile Outsourcing
Implementation of Lean and Agile
WIP
Lean Budgeting
Agile Marketing
Lean Software Development
chatgpt
An Appreciative Retrospective
Quality Assurance
Implementing SAFe
ATDD vs. BDD
Agile Games and Exercises
ART Success
ScrumMaster Tales
Advanced Roadmaps
Agile Product Development
Kanban Game
Iterative Incremental Development
Frameworks
ALM Tools
Achieve Business Agility
Scrum and XP
predictability
Confluence
Release Train Engineer
Agile Testing Practices
Legacy Code
Agile
Large Scale Scrum
Kanban Kickstart Example
SAFe
lean agile change management
Scrum Guide
Slides
Agile Israel Events
Manage Budget Creation
ROI
Presentation
Agile Risk Management
Pomodoro Technique
Agile Program
Built-In Quality
RTE
AI
Scrum Master Role
Development Value Streams
Agile Basics
Scrum Primer
DevOps
Lean Agile Leadership
Video
Agility
Rovo
Agile Exercises
Reading List
Agile Product Ownership
Agile for Embedded Systems
Acceptance Test-Driven Development
SA
Atlaassian
Nexus vs SAFe
Scrum Master
speed @ scale
Portfolio for Jira
Business Agility
Principles of Lean-Agile Leadership
What Is Kanban
Engineering Practices
System Team
Introduction to ATDD
Product Management
Agile Mindset
Lean Startup
Systems Thinking
Kaizen Workshop
Keith Sawyer
System Archetypes
Jira
agileisrael
transformation
Jira Cloud
Lean Agile Basics
Certified SAFe
GanttBan
Scrum
SPC
Operational Value Stream
Agile India
Effective Agile Retrospectives
Code
Risk Management on Agile Projects
Agile Delivery
Lean and Agile Techniques
Sprint Planning
Scrum.org
LPM
Perfection Game
Entrepreneurial Operating System®
Kanban Basics
Nexus
Introduction to Test Driven Development
Lean-Agile Software Development
POPM
Lean Agile
The Agile Coach
Self-organization
Jira admin
Agile Development
Professional Scrum Master
Software Development
Continuous Deployment
Managing Projects
Agile Release Management
Kanban
AI Artificial Intelligence
Scaled Agile Framework
Story Slicing
Kaizen
Agile Israel
Agile in the Enterprise
Applying Agile Methodology
The Kanban Method
User stories
Agile Release Planning
Agile Games
Limiting Work in Progress
RSA
LAB
Retrospectives
Agile Contracts Best Practices
Covid19
Hybrid Work
Legacy Enterprise
Accelerate Value Delivery At Scale
Amdocs
Kanban 101
EOS®
Product Ownership
speed at scale
IT Operations
Agile Techniques
Rapid RTC
Program Increment
Tools
BDD
SAFe Release Planning
Risk-aware Product Development
Agile Community
Continuous Improvement
Elastic Leadership
Value Streams
ATDD
Atlassian
Releases Using Lean
LeSS
Daily Scrum
Nexus and Kanban
TDD
SAFe DevOps
Process Improvement
Agile Project
Coaching Agile Teams
Agile Assembly Architecture
Managing Risk on Agile Projects
QA
Agile and DevOps Journey
Sprint Iteration
Lean and Agile Principles and Practices
Artificial Intelligence
NIT
PI Planning
ARTs
Lean Agile Organization
Lean Agile Management
Spotify
Continuous Delivery
Nexus Integration Team
Scrum With Kanban
Planning
Nexus and SAFe
Sprint Retrospectives
Software Development Estimation
Enterprise DevOps
Test Driven Development
Change Management
Lean Risk Management
Lean-Agile Budgeting
Professional Scrum with Kanban
Team Flow
A Kanban System for Software Engineering
Agile Project Management
Risk Management in Kanban
Jira Plans
Continuous Planning
Webinar
Professional Scrum Product Owner
Certification
Scrum Values
System Integration Environments
Continuous Integration
AgileSparks
Logo
Enable registration in settings - general

Contact Us

Request for additional information and prices

AgileSparks Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter, and stay updated on the latest Agile news and events

This website uses Cookies to provide a better experience
Shopping cart